Penny is overwhelmed with life and makes a wish that she never got married. Shirley the Christmas angel grants her wish and now she is a single and very successful executive. She seeks out her one time husband and things do go great.
Love interest: Her husband from the original timeline
Familiar Face: Cindy Williams as the Christmas angel
Who is dead: no one
Romantic ending: She figures out how to get back to her old life and they kiss by the tree